← Latest articles

Judge Denies Motion to Dismiss DRAM Price-Fixing Lawsuit Against Major Chipmakers

An SK hynix 8GB DDR4 SO-DIMM laptop memory module on a dark surface.
Photo credits
Photo: Suyash.dwivedi · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Cropped within the original photograph to 16:9, resized, and converted to WebP; no padding, extension or fabricated pixels.
SK hynix DDR4 memory (file photo).

A U.S. judge has rejected an attempt by the world’s three largest memory chip manufacturers to dismiss a class-action lawsuit accusing them of fixing prices and restricting supply. The ongoing legal challenge addresses significant price increases for computer memory.

Judge Noël Wise of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California denied the motion to dismiss filed by Micron, Samsung, and SK hynix. The lawsuit alleges that the three companies, which control about 90% of the global market for dynamic random-access memory (DRAM)—the short-term memory used in computers, phones, and servers—illegally coordinated to restrict supply and inflate prices.

The plaintiffs, a group of 17 individuals and small businesses, argue that memory prices surged by roughly 700% over a four-year period. They point to several parallel actions by the manufacturers, including simultaneous production cuts and a synchronized shift toward producing high-bandwidth memory (HBM)—a specialized, stacked memory type used in artificial intelligence hardware—which the lawsuit claims was used as a cover to curtail production of older memory modules.

The chipmakers argued that the lawsuit is merely a rerun of an earlier antitrust case from 2018 that was dismissed. They maintained that their production adjustments and business strategies were independent, logical responses to soaring market demand and strict competition.

Judge Wise rejected the argument that the companies were merely engaged in fierce competition, writing in the decision that the defendants' actions went beyond normal market behavior. The judge stated that their coordinated moves were more akin to “hawks flying in formation — an activity that hawks ordinarily do not do”.

While the ruling allows the lawsuit to move forward, it is not a final judgment on the merits of the case. Both sides must still present evidence and arguments before the court. The chipmakers have until December 7 to respond to the original complaint, with a case management conference scheduled for January 2027.

Summary

  • The court's decision allows the antitrust lawsuit to proceed, meaning the memory chipmakers may be forced to open internal communications to legal scrutiny.
  • The case addresses whether parallel production cuts and market shifts in a concentrated industry reflect illegal collusion or lawful business responses to surging demand for artificial intelligence hardware.