California Judge Denies Dismissal in RAM Price-Fixing Lawsuit Against Samsung, Micron, and SK Hynix

Photo credits
A California judge has denied a request to throw out a proposed class-action lawsuit accusing Samsung, Micron, and SK Hynix of conspiring to inflate memory chip prices. The legal battle centers on allegations that the three dominant manufacturers intentionally restricted supply to boost profits as demand surged.
Spiking prices for memory chips have driven up the cost of consumer electronics, including personal computers and video game consoles. While the memory industry attributes the recent price jumps to a massive rush to build data centers for artificial intelligence, the plaintiffs argue that the companies chose to withhold supplies rather than expand production to meet the rising demand.
The lawsuit alleges that the three companies coordinated their actions by making near-identical moves, such as reducing production simultaneously and shifting their manufacturing focus toward specialized server memory. According to the legal complaint, the manufacturers also introduced strict customer vetting and refused to sign long-term contracts. Plaintiffs argued in the court filing that in a truly competitive market, at least one company would have increased output to capture more sales rather than moving in lockstep.
Judge Noël Wise rejected the chipmakers' argument that the case was simply a repeat of earlier antitrust claims, noting that the plaintiffs had provided new evidence of possible collusion. Addressing the defendants' claim that they merely watch each other closely because of intense competition, the judge wrote in her court decision that their actions were more akin to “hawks flying in formation — an activity that hawks ordinarily do not do.”
The three companies have a history of antitrust scrutiny. They previously pleaded guilty to cartel-like behavior and price-fixing between 1998 and 2002, resulting in multimillion-dollar fines, though they successfully defeated a similar price-fixing lawsuit in 2018. In the current defense filings, Samsung, Micron, and SK Hynix maintained that their business moves were logical responses to market pressures and served their own independent self-interest.
The companies now have until December 7 to respond to the original complaint, with a case management conference scheduled for January 2027. It remains unclear how long the legal proceedings will take or whether the lawsuit will bring any near-term relief to consumers facing high RAM prices. Industry experts project that memory shortages and elevated prices will likely continue through much of 2027.
Summary
- The court’s decision allows the antitrust lawsuit to move forward, though the chipmakers have not been found guilty.
- Unresolved questions remain over whether the plaintiffs can prove intentional collusion during a period of extreme industry demand.