← Latest articles

Meta Warns It Could Remove WhatsApp and Other Services from Canada Over Encryption Bill

Mark Zuckerberg — file photograph.
Photo credits
Photo: Anthony Quintano from Westminster, United States · CC BY 2.0 · Cropped to 16:9 around visually reviewed head and subject bounds; resized and converted to WebP.
Mark Zuckerberg (file photo).

Meta representatives told a Senate committee that the company would have to consider removing its encryption services from Canada if the government’s proposed lawful access legislation passes without further amendments. The legislation, designated as Bill C-22, is currently undergoing study by the Senate’s national security committee.

The bill would require technology companies to alter their systems to give investigators the ability to hand over user information when armed with a warrant. It also grants the public safety minister authority to issue confidential orders requiring electronic service providers to build surveillance and monitoring capabilities into their networks. An independent intelligence commissioner would first review these orders.

During the committee hearings, Meta executives warned that the proposed requirements leave encrypted information vulnerable to malicious actors. Robyn Greene, Meta's director of privacy and public policy, told senators that the legislation mandates technical measures that contradict secure architecture.

"Ultimately, the Canadian government would be enforcing and imposing a law that it is not technically feasible to comply with and still offer secure, end-to-end encrypted services to Canadians," Greene told the committee.

When asked if the bill would result in the company pulling apps from the country, Rachel Curran, Meta's head of public policy for Canada, told senators that the company would have to review its options and consider removing its services. Meta's portfolio includes Facebook, Instagram, and the encrypted messaging application WhatsApp.

Curran argued that amendments previously introduced by Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree fail to adequately safeguard user data. "They have protected just the core and not the outside layers that are an integral part of the encryption process," she told senators.

Other encrypted communications platforms have adopted a similar stance during the parliamentary review. Udbhav Tiwari, vice-president at the messaging service Signal, testified that his company would withdraw from Canada rather than weaken its platform security. "If we are forced to choose between betraying our users and leaving Canada, we will not compromise the security of Canadians," Tiwari told the committee.

Apple also submitted that the government's amendments do not go far enough to preserve user privacy. Meanwhile, Privacy Commissioner Philippe Dufresne urged the Senate to enact further changes, noting that the bill would lower the legal threshold for law enforcement to access basic subscriber information from reasonable grounds to believe to reasonable grounds to suspect an offence has been or will be committed,.

The federal government defends the legislation as an essential framework to give law enforcement agencies the legal tools necessary to investigate modern crimes and protect the public. The Senate committee's study of the bill remains ongoing.

Summary

  • Meta and Signal warn they could remove their encrypted messaging services from Canada rather than comply with the security compromises required by Bill C-22.
  • The legislation faces intense debate in the Senate over how to balance law enforcement investigative powers with digital privacy and cybersecurity protection.