← Latest articles

Kalshi User Sues for $580,000 After Losing $308,000 on Sports Bets

King County Courthouse in Seattle, Washington.
Photo credits
Photo: Joe Mabel · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Reviewed 16:9 crop, resized and converted to WebP; no padding or generated extension.

A Washington man who lost more than $300,000 betting on sports through the prediction market Kalshi is suing the platform to recover over $580,000. The lawsuit asks a court to determine whether software matching buyers and sellers of event contracts operates as a federally regulated exchange or as an online casino banned by state law.

Over an eight-week period, Scott Bright moved $315,353.94 from his checking account into Kalshi through 253 separate bank debits. The platform turned those funds into more than $14.3 million worth of trades on baseball games, tennis matches and other sporting events. When he stopped trading, Bright had lost $308,781.62, while Kalshi had kept $89,651.76 in fees.

Bright filed his complaint in King County Superior Court, but Kalshi is seeking to move the case to federal court and has asked the judge to put proceedings on hold. The platform argues that Bright's positions were matched with other independent traders and settled on real-world outcomes, meaning his losses went to those counterparties rather than to Kalshi. The company describes itself as "a neutral exchange platform" with no financial stake in event results, generating revenue exclusively from transaction fees.

Bright contends that a Kalshi trading affiliate took the opposite side of many of his positions, which would make the platform a participant winning his money rather than a neutral venue. He acknowledges that he cannot prove this assertion without internal records. "The identity of the participant on the opposite side of each of Plaintiff's positions, and the profit each such participant realized, is information exclusively within Kalshi's possession," his complaint states.

Washington has prohibited internet gambling since 2006, and an older state statute allows individuals who lose money at illegal gambling to sue operators who profited. Kalshi counters that those rules do not apply because the trades were event contracts governed by the Commodity Exchange Act and regulated by the federal Commodity Futures Trading Commission. The company also noted that Bright does not allege anyone misled him about platform mechanics, fees or the risk of losing money.

The size of Bright's demand relies on a 1950 Washington Supreme Court decision, Heitfeld v. Benevolent and Protective Order of Keglers, which prevents wins on separate events from being netted against losses on others. Calculating each event independently brings his total demand to $580,544.98. If the court rejects that method, he seeks the return of all deposited funds and fees, totaling just over $405,000.

Kalshi wants Bright's case paused until the U.S. Supreme Court decides whether to take up a broader dispute over whether states can regulate the platform under local gambling laws. The company argued that a Supreme Court ruling would settle or simplify every claim and ensure consistent treatment for similar lawsuits.

Summary

The lawsuit highlights a central legal conflict over whether prediction markets offering sports wagers should be governed as federal financial exchanges or barred as illegal online gambling under state statutes.