DHS Has Used Administrative Subpoenas 185,000 Times Since Trump Took Office

Homeland Security Investigations estimates it has issued at least 185,000 administrative subpoenas since January 2025. The figure indicates a rapid expansion in how the Immigration and Customs Enforcement investigative wing utilizes its warrantless authority.
Historical Scale and Origins
To measure that volume against prior output, a previous analysis found that ICE agents issued roughly 170,000 customs summonses—a specific form of administrative subpoena—over a span of more than six and a half years between January 2016 and mid-August 2022. The recent 185,000 estimate emerged through a Freedom of Information Act lawsuit filed against the Department of Homeland Security by the Electronic Frontier Foundation. Aaron Mackey, deputy legal director at the nonprofit, stated that his organization aims to uncover finer details regarding the scope of the estimate.
Scope and Recent Targets
Administrative subpoenas function as an unchecked investigative mechanism, permitting the federal government to compel document production from private companies without demonstrating a formal need to a court. Since the current administration took office, federal authorities have deployed this subpoena power to pursue customer records concerning protesters and to unmask anonymous online critics. Specific examples include requests for customer lists identifying individuals in the Minneapolis-St. Paul area who purchased a particular green beanie from REI.
Legal Evolution and Administration Arguments
Congress initially established the customs summons nearly a century ago to allow customs inspectors to examine commercial import records and assess duties. Those statutory powers transferred to the Department of Homeland Security when the agency formed in 2003. Although the DHS inspector general criticized Customs and Border Protection in 2017 for attempting to use a customs summons to identify an anonymous social media poster outside of customs or immigration matters, the current administration argued in court that the agency may wield the authority across a broader portfolio beyond legacy enforcement boundaries.
Summary
The unprecedented volume of administrative subpoenas underscores how an unchecked investigative tool is being applied to gather broad digital records on protesters and critics. This practice has provoked sharp opposition from lawmakers and renewed calls for statutory curbs on federal surveillance powers.